DATELINE: Parallel Stories or Tag Teams?
Cast actually never appears together.
Not to be confused with dull plotting, Man in an Orange Shirt is a Masterpiece PBS drama.
The film is a complex examination of gay life across 60 years with a focus on two generations: the post-World War II veterans, and the modern 21st century. If there is any relief here, it is that this is not your typical gay story about randy American teenagers, charging out of closets.
However, the angst spreads over the decades. The older generation keeps a stiff upper lip and sucks in their tears, whereas the contemporary gay men let it all out. The tale is about a gay banker and his artist lover, separated by social convention and a wife in the 1940s. His grandson is also in the closet with a different inability to be monogamous, and never knew about his grandfather.
The stories share Vanessa Redgrave as the difficult grandmother, a painting of the man in an orange shirt, and a remote love-nest cottage, shared by the two divergent generations.
Suffering seems to be hereditary in this tale. Vanessa Redgrave took the role because her father, Michael Redgrave, was gay. She understood the sturm und drang in the script.
The cast includes Redgrave, Julian Sands in the modern tale, with Laura Carmichael (of Downton Abbey), and James McArdle in the past. As always, you have the best actors in the field, unlike American gay casts of beauty pageant boys.
Since England has been about 50 years ahead of the United States on the subject of homosexuality, it seems to have smaller moments of fraught tension. Young men forced themselves into a bisexual mold, whether it fit or not, in the old days.
Today’s gay men must fight to be faithful, and open relationships appear to be compromises that make for overwrought drama.
This is not your teenage gay disco dolly gay movie. Thank heavens.